I have written about how Chinese industrial espionage is not really traditional theft. It is a national strategy to skip the most expensive part of building an economy. Steal the blueprint, avoid the decade of research and the insane R&D costs. This week the US government accused six Chinese AI companies of doing exactly that to American AI, and the mechanism is almost poetic. They did not steal the models. They interviewed them.
The NSA, CISA, and the FBI issued a joint advisory naming DeepSeek, Moonshot AI, Alibaba, MiniMax, StepFun, and Z.ai. The accusation is these firms, likely with Beijing’s awareness, extracted billions of tokens across millions of requests from American frontier models, including Claude, ChatGPT, Gemini, and Grok, since late 2024. They then used those outputs to train their own competing systems.
Somehow I find this as unsurprising as the sun rising every morning.
The technique is known as distillation, and it is completely legit. Every major AI lab does it, American startups included. Basically, you take a big, expensive model and use its answers to train a smaller, less expensive one. It is a normal tool.
The accusation is not about using the tool. It is about the firms pointing their smaller models at someone else’s larger models at an industrial scale, wholly against the terms of use, to strip out the exact capabilities costing the most to build. The reasoning. The agentic behavior. The parts taking billions of dollars and years to create.
This is ironic AF if you stop and think about it for more than 12 seconds. American AI firms took intellectual property from all across the internet, at an industrial level, and thought it was OK. But now China is stealing what they stole, and they somehow feel wronged. You cannot invent a better, more asinine story.
Think about what this actually is. Training a frontier model from scratch is one of the most expensive things a company can do. The compute alone is an insane investment. The research is brutal.
Distillation lets you skip a massive portion of it. Why spend three years and a fortune teaching a model to reason when you can ask a model already capable of reasoning a few million questions and train on its homework? The advisory’s own words are the sharpest. Distillation was not a supplement to these companies’ development. It was the critical core of it.
This is the China playbook all over again, and should surprise absolutely no one. China does this in pretty much every market it wants to enter.
Do not pay for the invention. Acquire the result. It worked with jet engines, semiconductors, and pharmaceuticals. Now it is running against the single most expensive thing Silicon Valley is building nowadays. The target changed. The strategy did not. Why fund the research when you can copy the finish line?
One detail deserves attention, because it says something about where security is going. Use of US models is banned in China. Per the advisory, the firms allegedly used fraudulent accounts, VPNs, proxies, and automated agents to reach the American models, routing through relay servers outside mainland China to hide who was querying them.
The theft, if it can even be considered theft, does not look like a breach. It looks like a very large number of normal conversations. The firms deliberately spread those conversations across providers, accounts, proxies, and cloud platforms so no single company can see the entire operation. This is not just model theft. It is distributed collection. Each provider sees a handful of questions. Only the adversary sees the dataset being assembled.
Therein lies the whole problem. How do you stop someone from stealing your model when the method of stealing it is just everyday use of it?
Remember one thing. These are accusations from the US government at this juncture, and China has pushed back. Distillation is genuinely a gray area. The line between legitimate learning and industrial theft is real but blurry. The advisory is a political document as much as a technical one.
I have said the same thing about attribution. The confident public naming is not the end of the story. But the underlying pattern, using a rival’s finished product to skip the cost of building your own, is the most well-documented move in the entire history of Chinese industrial strategy, so the accusation lands quite securely on very familiar ground.
The US is now talking sanctions and Entity List designations, and telling its own labs to quietly feed degraded answers to suspected distillers rather than ban them. Read that again. The apparent defense against having your model copied is to quietly make its answers less useful to the copier.
And how does a model know whether the account doing the querying is legit or a distiller? Normal users will undoubtedly get caught up in these shenanigans, should the labs opt for such defensive measures.
AI companies have reached the point of being advised to poison their own outputs to protect them. The model is the crown jewel, the factory, and the battleground all at once.
You do not need to steal the thing anymore. You just need to ask it enough questions, and the most valuable machines America has built will answer every one of them, politely, until they have taught a rival how to build a better one.
Ask the laggard American auto industry how this ends. It watched China copy the electric car. Then it watched BYD pass it and take the lead. Copying is not the finish line. Sometimes it is the starting line for someone who runs faster than you.