Entities

Entities collected from this article, grouped for quick reference and copying. Inclusion does not establish malicious activity. Article links appear separately at the bottom as references.

Adam Mosseri, the apparent tool heading up Instagram for Meta, just argued against letting you turn off the algorithm. In doing so, he admitted exactly why the algorithm needs regulating. Beyond that, his argument is just wholly idiotic.

The admission came out of an Australian proposal. Australia wants to force platforms to give users a real choice, one tap to switch off the utterly annoying algorithmic feed and see posts the old-school way. Chronologically. Imagine that! Dear old Adam does not like this concept. Mosseri says engagement drops by as much as 50 percent when people turn off the algorithm. People spend a lot less time on the platform. Their satisfaction “falls off a cliff.” He offers all of this as evidence the opt-out is a bad idea.

Slow down and look at what he actually said. People who turn off the algorithm use Instagram less. To a company selling advertising against your attention, “you use it less” is the entire problem the algorithm exists to solve. Mosseri is not describing a worse experience for you. He is describing a worse outcome for Meta, and hoping you will not notice the difference. The more time people spend doomscrolling Instagram, the more annoying-AF advertisements for useless shit end up in their feeds.

To be fair, his actual argument is chronological feeds reward whoever posts the most. He claims brands and publishers will drown out your friends. Possibly. It still does not explain why everyone else should be denied the choice.

Time on app is not the same as value to the user. An algorithm tuned to maximize how long you scroll is not tuned to make your life better. Those two goals overlap at times, certainly. But when given the choice, people spend less time on Instagram.

That is not a bug in the chronological feed. It is people, freed from the machine, choosing to put the phone down. They open the app, see the updates from friends and family, and close the app. There is no need to endlessly scroll, hoping to find a recent update from a friend across the pond on business.

Notice the timing. This comes weeks after Meta agreed to pay up to US$16.68 billion to settle claims from 29 US states it deliberately designed its platforms to addict young people. In the settlement, Meta agreed to give US teens a non-personalized feed. So the company will hand over the off switch when a court forces it, and argue against the off switch everywhere a court has not. It will also likely bury the off switch in some nigh-impossible-to-find corner of settings.

Then there is the smaller tell. Mosseri admits the chronological feed already exists, but almost nobody uses it, only low single-digit percentages, and insists this is “not on purpose.” Cough BS cough. Maybe. But a company having mastered the art of making you tap exactly where it wants somehow could not make this one option easy to find. The same design genius keeping you scrolling could not manage a visible button on the main app screen. Decide for yourself how much of that to believe.

Mosseri also says Instagram is not addictive, a strange hill to die on in the same season his employer wrote a multibillion-dollar check over that exact accusation.

The honest version of his whole argument is short. The algorithm keeps you on the app longer than you would choose to stay on your own. He thinks this is a feature. The law calls it a harm.

The only real question is which of them describes your experience. You already know the answer. Given a choice, most people would pick a chronological feed and get two hours of their lives back every day.